Theory in anthropology since the sixties by felix girke my introductory remarks refer much less the content of ortners text, which would be the specificities of the different anthropological schools and movements mentioned, but rather the essay and its textual strategies and academic aims. I argued further that much of specifically middle class culture. Ortner was previously married to robert paul, a cultural anthropologist now at emory university. Ortner it is first and foremost a commitment to what geertz has called thickness, to producing understanding through richness, texture, and detail, rather than parsimony, refinement, and in the sense used by mathematicians elegance. My introductory remarks refer much less the content of ortners text. While slow to have a wider impact, the projectboth in. University of california, berkeley, professor of anthropology, 199496. Their paper invokes sherry ortner, who dismisses class as an objectivist discourse p.
Ortner grew up in a jewish family in newark, new jersey, and attended weequahic high school, as did philip roth and richie roberts. Ortner draws on her longstanding interest in theories of cultural practice to rethink key concepts of culture, agency, and subjectivity. Anth 400 week 12 anth 400 week 12 theory in anthropology. Ortner university of michigan presented at the panel, youth subcultures and styles. Feminist writers are continued to study of cultures, symbols and sexual stereotypes to analyze female subordination. She has been elected to the american academy of arts and sciences and has been awarded the retzius medal of the swedish society for anthropology and geography. Sherry ortner has a simple message in this pithy, readable essay, which adds to her influential series of meditations on trends within anthropological thought. As i discussed in an earlier essay ortner 1984, in the 1960s and 1970s american. She tries to describe the underlying logic behind it is that womens subordination is universal as, this condition not. The politics and erotics of culture by sherry b ortner book. In many ways sherry ortner is the anthropologists anthropologist. Ortner ortner starts off this chapter by describing a general mood of negativity and pessimism regarding the state of affairs in anthroplogy.
Pdf anthropology and social theory download read online. I was working on other kinds of things, my dissertation and my first book was with the sherpas and was about religion, and had nothing to do with gender at all. Madonna is portrayed as a masked dominatrix with a golden tooth and a whip. Sherry beth ortner is an american cultural anthropologist and has been a distinguished professor of anthropology at ucla since 2004.
Ortner is distinguished professor of anthropology at ucla. She studied anthropology at the university of chicago with clifford geertz and. This is a general interpretation of sherpa culture through examining the relationship between the sherpas buddhism and other aspects of their society, and a theoretical contribution to the study of ritual and religious symbolism. Ortner is professor of anthropology at columbia university. In this paper i try to expose the underlying logic of cultural thinking that assumes the inferiority of women. Ethnological society, society cultural anthropology. Society for the comparative study of society and history 1984. Cambridge up, 1981 435 pages a standard work on anthropology, looking into the sexual customs and patterns of simple tribes. In this book, ortner draws on her more than two decades of work in feminist anthropology to offer a major reconsideration of culture and gender. In the essay, sewell cites ortners 1984 piece theory in anthropology since the sixties, and includes ortner among several scholars he thanks for feedback on his ajs piece. Explore the factchecked online encyclopedia from encyclopaedia britannica with hundreds of thousands of objective articles, biographies, videos, and images from experts. What is the underlying logic behind sherry ortners.
Her final book on the sherpas, life and death on mt. Contemporary authors, new revision series dictionary. One might even say that it is the only genuinely original social scienceparadigmand humanitiestoo, for that matterto be developed in the twen. Ortner draws on her longstanding interest in theories of cultural practice to rethink key concepts of culture, agency, and subjectivity for the social sciences of the twentyfirst century. This collection of essays three new, five drawn from close to a quartercentury of scholarship shows ortner scrutinizing her own work as carefully as that of any other scholar in order to move beyond it. Ortner in anthropology and social theory the awardwinning anthropologist sherry b. Sherry beth ortner born september 19, 1941 is an american cultural anthropologist and has.
It clearly explaines the rise of new practice theory in the field of anthropological research, and structureagency tensions in the researching of organizations and organizing. I had hoped to include a discussion of postmodernity in this essay, but i have run out of time and space. In addition she has done extensive ethnographic fieldwork in nepal and the united states. Pdf theory in anthropology since the sixties researchgate. The cultural construction of gender and sexuality, sherry b. Ortner we cannot rout out simply by rearranging a few tasks and roles in the social system, or even by reordering the whole economic structure. A cultural and political history of sherpa buddhism.
Sherry ortner was awarded a macarthur genius grantin 1990. Ortner upheaval was characteristic of many other fields in that era. Sherry beth ortner born september 19, 1941 is an american cultural anthropologist and has been a distinguished professor of anthropology at ucla since 2004. Ortner draws on her longstanding interest in theories of cultural practice to rethink key concepts of culture, agency, and subjectivity for the social sciences of the twentyfirst century the seven theoretical and interpretive essays in this volume each advocate reconfiguring, rather than abandoning, the concept of. Throughout the book, however, there is a running, and ambivalent, counterpoint with the.
Pdf land tenure and transfer in chimbu, papua new guinea. World heritage encyclopedia, the aggregation of the largest online encyclopedias available, and the most definitive collection ever assembled. Duke university press anthropology and social theory. She is a longtime contributor to anthropological and feminist theory.
Sherpas through their rituals cambridge studies in cultural systems kindle edition by ortner, sherry b download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The sherpas of the himalayas practice tibetan buddhism, a variety of mahayana buddhism. As i discussed in an earlier essay ortner 1984, in the 1960s and 1970s. Montages of sexual imagery are shown that are shot during the photography of madonnas sex book. In 1984, sherry ortner published a paper entitled theory in. States how the period of theoretical orientation and debate between the different schools has been replaced with growing apathy, with anthropologist no longer chosing to.
These are dark times, times to which todays cultural anthropologists are being true when they write dark ethnographies, using dark theory to bring its lineaments to light. A cultural and political history of sherpa buddhism and culturepowerhistory. Ortner names neoliberalism as the axis that sustains the dialectic. Land tenure and transfer in chimbu, papua new guinea. Online shopping from a great selection at books store. Sherry ortner is an anthropologist who specializes in social and cultural theory, feminist theory, and the cultural, political, and historical dimensions of ethnography. The forms that ethnographic thickness have taken have of course changed over time. Theory in anthropology since the sixties by felix girke my introductory remarks refer much less the content of ortners text, which would be the specificities of the different anthropological schools and movements mentioned, but rather the essay and its. The cultural construction of gender and sexuality cambridge, uk. The politics and erotics of culture is a graceful model of how thoughts evolve and how scholars grow.
Historical contexts, internal debates, and ethical practice. This is an eloaborate summary of the pages 144166 from the article of sherry ortner of theory in antropology 1984. Ortner abstract in this article i consider several emergent trends in anthropology since the 1980s against a backdrop of the rise of neoliberalism as both an economic and a governmental formation. The cultural construction of gender and sexuality by sherry b. Comparative studies in society and history, 26 1, 126166.
Ortner much of the creativity of anthropology derives from the tension between two sets of demands. This essay ties together two projects in which ortner has long been engaged the development of practice theory and of feminist theory in anthropology and which she confesses she has failed to fully unify see also. By this i mean not just that shes an exemplary model of the craft though shes obviously that, or even precisely that she analyzes anthropologys own myths and rituals, but, rather, that she has an uncanny ability to do for her own discipline, at any point in its history, what any good ethnographer should do with a. Sherpas through their rituals cambridge studies in. Sherry ortner was awarded a macarthur genius grant in 1990. It concentrates on the works of clifford geertz, victor turner, david schneider, mary douglas, and sherry ortner, since each of these thinkers has been seminal in developing this approach. Ortner and others published theory in anthropology since the sixties find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Fiona hsieh, june lee, renee ho personal life born and raised in newark, new jersey middleclass family wanted to step out of privileged life where did she study. The reemergence of resistance, in her account, harkens back to the period just after her 1984 essay leaves off citing comaroff 1985, among others. Today, resistance theory is renewed with a difference. Each culture begins with the biological differences between the sexes. Theory in anthropology since the sixties comparative studies in. I feel like this quote strongly connects to our recent classroom debates regarding the social and cultural views of women as described by judith butler and sherry ortner.
Theory in anthropology since the sixties 5structuralismstructuralism, the moreorless singlehanded invention of claude levistrauss, was the only genuinely new paradigmto be developed in the sixties. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Nov 30, 2006 in anthropology and social theory the awardwinning anthropologist sherry b. Theory in anthropology since the sixties by felix girke my introductory remarks refer much less the content of ortner s text, which would be the specificities of the different anthropological schools and movements mentioned, but rather the essay and its textual strategies and academic aims.
Theory in anthropology since the sixties volume 26 issue 1 sherry b. Ortner grew up in a jewish family in newark, new jersey, attended weequahic high school, as did philip roth and richie roberts, she received her b. Guggengheim fellow, 19821983, mac arthur fellow, 19901995. As this footnote suggests, it may have been sherry ortner who motivated his conceptualization.
This collection of essays three new, five drawn from close to a quartercentury of scholarship shows ortner. As you have mentioned, gender was not my original focus in terms of my early work, and actually when i was in graduate school feminist anthropology did not exist. Before coming to ucla in 2004, she taught at sarah lawrence college, the university of michigan, the university of california, berkeley, and columbia university. An early formulator of the notion of the cultural construction of gender, she pioneered an investigation of. Theory in anthropology since the sixties sherry ortner. Ethnological society invited session, author meets critics. Ortner and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. An early formulator of the notion of the cultural construction of gender, she pioneered an investigation of this process in a comparative perspective. Independent film at the twilight of the american dream duke university press, 20. It is a montage of sexually charged images, designed to shock the audience. Updating practice theory, anthropology and social theory. Nov 26, 2012 theory in anthropology since the sixtiesauthors.
The fictional comic book character branded as singularity, is among the latest to join the new marvel aforce which is comprised of an allfemale roster. The session proposal written, i believe, by the aes program chair, katherine verdery read as follows. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading sherpas through their rituals cambridge studies in cultural systems. Ortner has 16 books on goodreads with 2542 ratings. Anth 400 week 12 theory in anthropology since the sixties 1984 by sherry b. Sherri ortner, a feminist anthropologist expresses this problem on her essay is female to male as nature is to culture. Sherry ortner and theory in anthropology, held at the american anthropological association meetings in chicago. In literary criticism, for example, by the 1960s a volatile mixture of linguistics, psychoanalysis and semiotics, structuralism, marxist theory and reception aesthetics had begun to replace the older moral humanism. Censored and uncensored versions of the video exist. Purification rite, any of the ceremonial acts or customs employed in an attempt to. A reader in contemporary social theory coedited with nicholas b. The seven theoretical and interpretive essays in this volume each advocate.
332 1166 1096 521 839 583 1169 603 79 636 338 1218 1134 95 796 1168 1059 1532 395 424 672 528 1126 266 1013 1495 3 679 1435 959 607 154 169 1472 764 201 1161 666 512 225 993 920